Skip to Main Content

Investor Basics

Auction Rate Securities

Auction rate securities (ARS) are long-term bonds or preferred shares whose interest or dividend rate resets at scheduled auctions, often weekly or monthly.
Also Called
  • ARS
  • Auction Rate Bonds
  • Auction Rate Preferred Securities
By InsiderFinance TeamUpdated Sources & Methodology

Separate the Rate Reset From the Sale Result

Failed-auction procedures can allocate partial sales. The example’s hold order keeps the full interest calculation intact.
Auction ResultRate for Next PeriodTransfer Outcome
Clearing Example3.50%Eligible sell orders clear
Failed Example7.00% fallbackUnfilled balances remain
Investor’s Hold Order$1,361.11 interestKeeps $250,000 par
Failed-auction procedures can allocate partial sales. The example’s hold order keeps the full interest calculation intact.
On This Page
  1. What are auction rate securities?
  2. How an ARS auction works
  3. ARS failed auction example: income at the maximum rate
  4. The 2008 auction rate securities market freeze
  5. How to evaluate a legacy ARS position
  6. Lessons from ARS for other income products
  7. Limitations of auction rate securities
  8. Bottom line
  9. FAQ

Key Takeaways

  • Auction-rate bonds pay interest; auction-rate preferred shares pay dividends. Short reset periods operate inside long-term or perpetual instruments.
  • A reset auction matches transfer orders under the program’s procedures. A failed auction can leave sell orders partly or entirely unfilled.
  • A failed auction pays the contractual fallback rate, and unfilled sell orders stay with their holders at that rate.
  • Dealers routinely bid for their own accounts to keep auctions clearing, and Federal Reserve research found they absorbed more than 40 percent of municipal ARS offered on a typical pre-crisis auction day.
  • Dealer support ended in February 2008, the auction failure rate peaked at 85 percent on February 13, and new ARS issuance effectively stopped after the collapse.

What are auction rate securities?

Auction rate securities (ARS) are long-term bonds or preferred shares with distribution rates reset at scheduled auctions. A seven-day or monthly reset changes the rate; it does not shorten a bond’s final maturity or create a maturity for perpetual preferred shares. When an auction fails, the rate moves to a contractual fallback and unfilled sell orders stay with their holders.

The instrument’s documents specify the auction interval, bidding procedures, rate limits and transfer rules. Debt pays interest. Preferred shares pay dividends and use their own redemption and liquidation terms.

How an ARS auction works

Existing holders submit hold, sell or rate-conditioned orders. Prospective buyers bid for an amount at a required rate. The auction agent applies the program’s allocation rules and determines the rate for the next period.

After transfers settle, the next-period rate applies to the positions held for that period under the payment terms. A seller does not keep earning that new period’s distribution on securities already sold.

An all-hold result and a failed auction each pay the rate the offering documents set for that case. When an auction fails, available bids can support partial transfers under some procedures; unfilled balances remain invested. A failure resets the rate and leaves the unsold balances in place, so check both results after every auction: the new rate and what actually sold.

Formula

Period interest = retained bond par × annual reset rate × days in period / day-count basis
  • Par value is the face amount the security pays interest on, $250,000 in the example.
  • The reset rate is the clearing rate produced by the auction, meaning the lowest rate at which every security offered for sale finds a buyer.
  • Day-count conventions vary by program and can use 360 or 365 days.
  • The maximum rate is a formula in the offering documents, such as a multiple of or spread over a short-term reference rate.

ARS failed auction example: income at the maximum rate

An investor holds $250,000 par of a municipal auction-rate bond and submits a hold order for the next reset. The program uses a 28-day period, Actual/360 interest and a failed-auction rate equal to 175% of a short-term reference rate. The previous period cleared at 3.50%.

  • Interest for the cleared period: $250,000 × 0.035 × (28 / 360) = $680.56
  • The next auction receives sell orders for $40 million against buy orders for $22 million, so it fails.
  • Reference rate 4.00 percent × 1.75 = 7.00 percent maximum rate for the following period
  • Interest at the maximum rate: $250,000 × 0.07 × (28 / 360) = $1,361.11

The hold order leaves $250,000 invested. Its 28-day interest rises from $680.56 at 3.50% to $1,361.11 at the 7.00% fallback rate. With $40 million of sell orders against $22 million of bids, at most $22 million sells; the auction procedures decide whose orders fill, and the unsold balance stays with its holders.

The next auction has $40 million of sell orders against $22 million of bids. It does not fully clear. Its contractual rate formula applies 175% to a 4% reference rate, producing 7%.

The investor’s unchanged $250,000 holding earns $1,361.11 for the next twenty-eight-day period. Other holders’ proceeds and remaining balances follow the auction’s transfer rules. The 7% rate pays the holders who wanted out double the interest to stay in, and their unfilled orders wait for the next auction.

The 2008 auction rate securities market freeze

Federal Reserve research found that dealers bought more than 40% of municipal ARS offered on a typical pre-crisis auction day. That support was discretionary. As dealers withdrew in February 2008, the auction failure rate peaked at 85% on February 13.

When that support stopped, rate resets continued under fallback provisions, issuers kept owing their payments, and holders sat on unfilled sale orders. The reset schedule carried no right to sell.

How to evaluate a legacy ARS position

Start with the security identifier and offering documents. Find the latest rate notice, auction outcome, transfer procedure and any issuer redemption or tender offer. Legacy auction preferred shares continue to appear in issuer filings.

A negotiated sale, a tender and an issuer redemption each have their own price and settlement terms. Use the completed transaction’s terms to calculate proceeds instead of treating a reset date as a cash-out date.

Lessons from ARS for other income products

When comparing income products, identify the maturity, any put or redemption right, the party obligated to pay and the process for selling beforehand. Then sort the exits into the ones the contract guarantees, such as a put or a redemption right, and the ones that need a buyer to show up.

That sequence connects the quoted income with the actual cash-flow and exit terms. It is the useful lesson for a trader evaluating any position that serves as reserve capital.

Limitations of auction rate securities

  • Identify a contractual exit before you count on selling. A reset schedule is not a right to sell: an auction transfers securities only when bids match sell orders, and no party is obligated to buy.
  • Price the exit separately from the rate. A higher fallback rate does not create liquidity: in the example, the 7% rate doubles the period’s interest to $1,361.11, but the $40 million of sell orders still meets only $22 million of bids.
  • Check who was bidding before you read a clearing record as investor demand. Before 2008, dealers bought more than 40% of municipal ARS offered on a typical auction day, and that support was discretionary.
  • Price each exit on its own terms. Where auctions still fail, a legacy position exits through a negotiated sale, tender or redemption, each with its own price.
  • Judge the issuer’s ability to pay from its payment record and financials, because an auction result measures liquidity.

Bottom line

Auction rate securities pair a long-term bond or preferred share with a short-term rate reset, and the 2008 failures showed that the reset schedule never guaranteed a sale. Judge any holding by its maturity, maximum-rate formula, transfer procedures and redemption or tender terms, not by how often its rate changes.

Clear answers

Frequently Asked Questions

Sources and Further Reading

  1. Federal Reserve: The Fragility of Discretionary Liquidity Provision, Lessons from the Collapse of the Auction Rate Securities Market
  2. MSRB EMMA: Understanding Auction Rate Securities Data
  3. Congressional Research Service: Auction-Rate Securities (RL34672)

How entries are sourced, calculated and updated: editorial methodology.

Continue learning